Domestic service

CONTENTS

PAGE
CHAPTER I
Introduction
Frequency of discussion of domestic service 1
Personal character of the discussion 2
Omission of the subject from economic discussion 2
General reasons for this omission 2
Specific reasons for this omission 4
Fundamental reason for this omission 5
Can this omission be justified? 6
CHAPTER II
Historical Aspects of Domestic Employments
Condition of industries in the eighteenth century 7
Inventions of the latter part of the century 7
Immediate result of these inventions 8
Co-operating influences 8
Effect of inventions on household employments 9
Release of work from the household 9
Diversion of labor from the household to other places 10
Results of this diversion to other places 11
Diversion of labor from the household into other channels 11
Household labor becomes idle labor 12
Outlets for idle labor 12
General result of change of work in the household 13
Division of labor in the household only partial 13
Interdependence of all industries 15
CHAPTER III
Domestic Service during the Colonial Period
Domestic service has a history 16
Three periods of this history 16
The colonial period 16
Classes of servants during this period 17
Early reasons for colonizing America 17
Advantage to England of disposing of her undesirable population 17
Protests against this method of settlement 18
The freewillers 19
Proportion of redemptioners 20
Place of birth of redemptioners 20
Social condition of redemptioners 21
Methods of securing redemptioners 22
Form of indenture 22
Servants without indenture 22
Virginia law in regard to servants without indenture 23
Early condition of redemptioners 25
Subsequent improvement in condition 27
Wages of redemptioners 28
Legal regulation of wages 30
Character of service rendered by redemptioners 31
Service in Virginia 32
Service in Maine 33
Service in Massachusetts 34
Colonial legislation in regard to masters and servants 37
Laws for the protection of servants 38
Physical protection 39
Laws for the protection of masters 40
Laws in regard to runaways 40
Harboring runaways 41
Inducements to return runaways 43
Corporal punishment 44
Trading or bartering with servants 45
Miscellaneous laws protecting masters 46
Obligation of masters to community 47
Redemptioners after expiration of service 48
Indian servants 49
Negro slavery 51
General summary of character of service during the colonial period 52
CHAPTER IV
Domestic Service since the Colonial Period
Second period in history of domestic service 54
Substitution for redemptioners of American “help” 54
Democratic condition of service 55
Observations of European travellers 55
Characteristics of the period 61
Third period in the history of domestic service 62
The Irish famine of 1846 62
The German revolution of 1848 63
Opening of treaty relations with China in 1844 64
Abolition of slavery in 1863 65
Effect of these movements on domestic service 65
Development of material resources 66
Effect of this on domestic service 67
Immobility of labor of women 68
Change in service indicated by history of the word “servant” 69
Early meaning of the word “servant” 69
Use of word “help” 70
Reintroduction of word “servant” 71
Impossibility of restoring previous conditions of service 72
CHAPTER V
Economic Phases of Domestic Service
Domestic service amenable to economic law 74
Many domestic employees of foreign birth 74
Geographical distribution of foreign born employees 75
Concentration of foreign born women in remunerative occupations on domestic service 77
The foreign born seek the large cities 77
Foreign countries having the largest representation in large cities 78
Foreign countries having the largest representation in domestic service 78
Conclusion in regard to foreign born domestic employees 80
General distribution of domestic employees 80
Domestic employees few in agricultural states 80
The number large in states with large urban population 80
The number not affected by aggregate wealth 82
The number somewhat affected by per capita wealth 82
Domestic employees found in largest numbers in large cities 83
Proportion of domestic employees varies with geographical location and prevailing industry 84
Neither aggregate nor per capita wealth determines number of domestic employees in cities 86
Prevailing industry of city determines number of domestic servants 87
Competition for domestics between wealth and manufacturing industries 88
Wages in domestic service 88
Conformity of wages to general economic conditions 89
Skilled labor commands higher wages than unskilled labor 89
The skilled laborer a better workman than the unskilled 90
The foreign born receive higher wages than the native born 91
Men receive higher wages in domestic service than women 92
Tendency towards increase in wages 93
Comparison of wages in domestic service with wages of women in other occupations 93
High wages in domestic service do not counterbalance advantages in other occupations 103
Domestic service offers few opportunities for promotion 103
Time unemployed in domestic service 104
High wages maintained without strikes 105
Conclusions in regard to wages in domestic service 106
Conclusions in regard to general economic conditions 106
CHAPTER VI
Difficulties in Domestic Service from the Standpoint of the Employer
Conditions of the average family 107
Difficulties in domestic service 108
Prevalence of foreign born employees 108
Restlessness among employees 109
Employment in skilled labor of unskilled laborers 112
Difficulty in changing employees 114
Recommendations of employers 114
The employment bureau 115
Indifference of employers to economic law 117
Illustrations of this indifference 117
Difference between the employers of domestic labor and other employers 121
Difficulties considered are not personal 122
Difficulties not decreasing 125
Difficulties not confined to America 127
The question in England 127
Condition of service in Germany 128
Service in France 129
Summary of difficulties 129
CHAPTER VII
Advantages in Domestic Service
Personnel in domestic service 130
Reasons why women enter domestic service 131
High wages 131
Occupation healthful 132
It gives externals of home life 133
Special home privileges 133
Free time during the week 134
Annual vacations 135
Knowledge of household affairs 137
Congenial employment 137
Legal protection 138
Summary of advantages 138
CHAPTER VIII
The Industrial Disadvantages of Domestic Service
Reasons why women do not choose domestic service 140
No opportunity for promotion 141
Work in itself not difficult 142
“Housework is never done” 142
Lack of organization 143
Irregularity of working hours 143
Work required evenings and Sundays 146
Competition with the foreign born and negroes 146
Lack of independence 147
Summary of industrial disadvantages 149
CHAPTER IX
The Social Disadvantages of Domestic Service
Lack of home life 151
Lack of social opportunities 152
Lack of intellectual opportunities 153
Badges of social inferiority 154
Use of word “servant” 155
The Christian name in address 156
The cap and apron 157
Acknowledgment of social inferiority 158
Giving of fees 158
Objections to feeing system 159
Excuses made for it 161
Other phases of social inferiority 162
Social inferiority overbalances industrial advantages of the occupation 163
Comparison of advantages and disadvantages of the occupation 165
CHAPTER X
Doubtful Remedies
Difference of opinion in regard to remedies possible 167
General principles to be applied 168
The golden rule 169
Capability and intelligence of employer 170
Receiving the employee into the family life of the employer 170
Importation of negroes from the South 172
Importation of Chinese 176
Granting of licenses 177
German service books 178
Convention of housekeepers 179
Abolishing the public school system 179
“Servant Reform Association” 179
Training schools for servants 180
Advantages of such schools 180
Practical difficulties in the way 182
Not in harmony with present conditions 184
Co-operative housekeeping 186
Advantages of the plan 187
Objections to it 188
Practical difficulties in carrying it out 190
Co-operative boarding 191
Objections to the plan 192
Mr. Bellamy’s plan 192
Reasons for considering these proposed measures impracticable 193
CHAPTER XI
Possible Remedies—General Principles
Remedies must take into account past and present conditions 194
Industrial tendencies 194
Concentration of capital and labor 194
Specialization of labor 195
Associations for mutual benefit 195
Specialization of education 195
Profit sharing 196
Industrial independence of women 196
Helping persons to help themselves 196
Publicity in business affairs 197
The question at issue 198
Impossibility of finding a panacea 199
General measures 199
Truer theoretical conception of place of household employments 199
A more just estimate of their practical importance 200
Removal of prejudice against housework 201
Correction of misconceptions in regard to remuneration for women’s work 201
Summary of general principles 203
CHAPTER XII
Possible Remedies—Improvement in Social Condition
Social disadvantages 204
Possibility of removing them 204
Provision for social enjoyment 205
Abolishing the word “servant” 207
Disuse of the Christian name in address 209
Regulation of use of the cap and apron 209
Abandoning of servility of manner 210
Principles involved in freeing domestic service from social objections 211
CHAPTER XIII
Possible Remedies—Specialization of Household Employments
Putting household employments on a business basis 212
Articles formerly made only in the household 212
Articles in a transitional state 213
Articles now usually made in the house 213
Removal of work from the household 215
This change in line with industrial development 215
Indications of its ultimate prevalence 216
The Woman’s Exchange 217
The opening up to women of a new occupation 218
Ultimate preparation of most articles of food outside of the individual home 219
Advantages of this plan 219
Objections raised to it 221
These objections not valid 221
Laundry work done out of the house 222
Advantages of the plan 223
Possibility of having work done by the hour, day, or piece 223
Improved method of purchasing household supplies 225
Operation of unconscious business co-operation 226
General advantages of specialization of household employments 228
Objections raised to the plan 230
These objections not valid 231
Illustrations of success of the plan 233
CHAPTER XIV
Possible Remedies—Profit Sharing
Industrial disadvantages of domestic service 235
Industrial difficulties in other occupations still unsettled 236
Possible relief through profit sharing 236
Definition of profit sharing 236
History of profit sharing 237
Advantages of profit sharing in other occupations 237
Lessons to be learned from profit sharing 240
Domestic service wealth consuming rather than wealth producing 240
The wage system not satisfactory in the occupation 241
Application of the principle of profit sharing to the household 242
Advantages of the plan in the household 244
Its advantages in hotels, restaurants, and railroad service 244
Substitution of profit sharing for fees 244
Objections to profit sharing in the household 245
These objections do not hold 246
Experiments in profit sharing in the household 248
CHAPTER XV
Possible Remedies—Education in Household Affairs
Lack of information one obstacle in the household 251
Difference between information and education 251
What is included in information 251
Difficulty of obtaining information in regard to the household 252
Advance in other occupations through publicity of all information gained 252
What is included in education 252
Information and education necessary in the household 254
Progress hindered through lack of these 254
Cause of inactivity in household affairs 254
Assumption that knowledge of the household comes by instinct 254
Assumption that household affairs concern only women 256
Belief that all women have genius for household affairs 257
Theory that household affairs are best learned at home 258
Tendencies in the opposite direction 259
Establishment of school of investigation 259
Necessity for investigation before progress can be made 260
CHAPTER XVI
Conclusion
Summary of points considered 263
Failure to recognize industrial character of domestic service 264
Conservatism of women 264
Summary of difficulties 265
Explanation of difficulties 265
Responsibility of all employers 266
Results to be expected from investigation 266
Removal of social stigma 266
Simplification of manner of life 267
Household employments on a business basis 268
Profit sharing 268
Investigation of household affairs 269
Readjustment of work of both men and women 270
Difficulty of dealing with women as an economic factor 270
Advantages of their working for remuneration 272
Division of labor in the household 272
Reform possible only through use of existing means 273
General conclusion 274
CHAPTER XVII
Domestic Service in Europe
Opinion held in America 275
Ideal service not found in Europe 275
Influences that affect the question 276
External conditions that affect the question 277
Architecture a factor in the problem 277
Difficulties of the European employer 278
Advantages of service in Europe 280
Baking and laundry done out of the house 280
Legal contracts in Germany 281
The German service book 284
Employment of men 286
Wages in domestic service in Europe 288
Supplementary fees and profits 290
Allowances 292
Insurance 292
Difficulty of determining exact wages 293
Character of the service 294
Other factors affecting the question 295
Social condition of the employee 296
In England 297
In France 299
In Italy 299
Benefactions for servants in Germany 299
Conclusion 301
Appendix I. Copy of schedules distributed 305
Appendix II. List of places from which replies to schedules were received 314
Appendix III. Circular sent out by the social science section of the Civic Club of Philadelphia 315
Bibliography 317
Index 323